Feb 4th 2012, 6:28:36
Dagga asked for thoughts. I provided thoughts that question whether such a system has merit. You felt I was going off-topic and "hijacking the thread". I felt it is not.
I could also claim that you are arrogant when you say that you THINK Dagga's thread is about discussing the implementation and not on the merits of the idea, and what you THINK he intended.
When I disagreed with Hanlong, he justified his ELO system by providing merits. Likewise, Dagga has justified the merits when I questioned it (about whether the system is better than a fixed date).
To each his own.
Originally posted by Detmer:
That is rather arrogant of you to be sure you know Dagga's intent when it is not what he specified. I do think this is a topic that Dagga has thought over and that when he said he wanted to discuss random systems that is actually what he intended.
I could also claim that you are arrogant when you say that you THINK Dagga's thread is about discussing the implementation and not on the merits of the idea, and what you THINK he intended.
When I disagreed with Hanlong, he justified his ELO system by providing merits. Likewise, Dagga has justified the merits when I questioned it (about whether the system is better than a fixed date).
To each his own.